It has been more than a year since your posting to the Goff Family site, so you may have solved your mystery. I too am searching for NY Goffs: the parents of Sophia Catherine Goff who was born 1819 in Orange, Monroe County, NY and died NYC 1889. She married Silas Witherbee in 1842. Since Sarah's and Sophia's birth years are similar, they could be siblings or cousins (or not related at all). If you have any information on Goff's in Orange or Monroe County, I would appreciate it. If I encounter Sarah in my searches, I will let you know.